Skip to main content

My Dearest Naomi

Title:  My Dearest Naomi
Author:  Jerry & Tina Eicher
Pages:  336
Year:  2012
Publisher:  Harvest House Publishers
Note:  A complimentary copy was provided for an honest review.  Follow me on twitter @lcjohnson1988 or on my website:

                When I consider reading a novel, it is never with the intent of reading it in letter form.  While this may attract some attention if dispersed within the framework of telling a story, I found the format of this novel tedious.  While reading an occasional letter from one party to another is very interesting and enhances the work of fiction, it was very hard to be interested and to engage with this work because it is just a compilation of letters.
                Eugene is an Amish young man who had taught in the Amish community in Indiana for a year.  At the beginning of the book, Eugene and Naomi are promised to each other before he decides to accept a position to teach for nine months in Iowa at a Mennonite school.  Throughout this these letters based on the authors’ real life, there is a smattering of German words, which adds a flavor to the fictional characters writing the letters.  Naomi continues to work while Eugene gets settled at his job in another state as a school teacher.
                What makes this a monotonous and uninteresting book is that the letters include many of the exacting details of their everyday lives.  The letters are dated and of various lengths, but include multiple days of routine of their daily lives.  In addition to this, the letters allow no time to pass before another one is written that includes everything that happens throughout the day.  While it is attractive to know that it is based on the love that was building between the authors, nevertheless writing without any unusual or imaginative events makes the book unappealing. 
                Therefore, while some may enjoy Amish stories, this one unfortunately I find isn’t a gem.  The reasons for this are it lacks in flowing within the framework of telling a story.  There is no plot, suspense, imagination, and nothing to capture the attention of the reader.
My rating for My Dearest Naomi out of 5 stars possible is 2 stars at most.
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Lily of the Manor

Title:Lily of the Manor
Author:Anita Stansfield
Publisher: Covenant Communications
My rating is 4 stars out of 5.
Lily Broadbent is a wealthy widow who has adopted 11 orphan children.She would pray before entering an orphanage as to whom she should adopt and leave the rest to God.She needs of a tutor for her brood and Frederick Woodstone needs a tutoring position.He journeys to Broadbent Manor, hoping to get the job and to start immediately so he doesn’t have to pay another night’s rent at the local inn as his funds are rapidly dwindling.He meets Lily and is struck by her very different appearance.She puts him at ease and lets him know she is used to getting looked at.He and she strike up an instant rapport and he is hired on the spot.He begins the next day with Lily observing his methods of teaching as well as discipline for her children.She is most impressed with how Frederick interacts with and encourages her children.
As the story progresses, Lily and Frederick spend …

Innocent Lies (Hidden Truth #4)

Title:Innocent Lies (Hidden Truth #4)
Author: Robin Patchen
Pages: 346
Year: 2018
Publisher: Create Space
My rating is 5 out of 5 stars.
This whole series is so worth reading! They excel at suspense and grabbing the heart of the reader, pulling them into the plethora of happenings in the book. The series has a total of four books that can be read as stand-alone stories though I found reading them in order helped enhance my understanding of the plot and characters.
The titles in order are: Convenient Lies, Twisted Lies followed by Generous Lies, which comes before this final novel I am sharing my thoughts on today.Robin weaves such a well-crafted plot that brings the reader into the story from the first page, and then keep turning the pages with all the twists and turns in the plot.I felt like I was right there observing what was happening around me even though I was reading the book.
Time flew by quickly and I was unaware of what was going on around me because I was lost in the pages!Right th…


Title:  Fugitive Trackdown (Love Inspired Suspense)
Author:  Sandra Robbins
Pages:  224
Year:  Feb 2015
Publisher:  Love Inspired
My rating is 5 stars.
Claire Walker begins tracking down a fugitive after her father’s passing and learning the amount of debt owed by the business by bail jumpers.  Claire is very much living unprepared in her new though temporary life as her education as a librarian gives her little real life experience.  Claire’s best friend, Jessica, is a former police officer with her family’s fugitive recovery company a wonderful fit, but Claire just can’t ask her friend to help for reasons readers will discover.
The tracking down of a fugitive leads to a lost romance memory when she is aided unwillingly by Adam, Jessica’s brother.  Adam, a former soldier, has the training and knowledge he uses for the family business, but where has Adam’s faith gone since he last spoke to Claire?  When Claire and Adam are facing a life threatening experience their hearts, hurts and spirit…